Many,
myself included, gripe about the way too early start to the Christmas
holiday shopping season. It seems as though the moment Linus wakes up
in pumpkin patch on November 1st (with the Great Pumpkin
once again stiffing him) the holiday advertisements begin.
What
also starts just as early now-a-days is the 24 hour non-stop holiday
music on some radio stations. For whatever reason, as much as I hate
the November start to the shopping season, I enjoy the music aspect.
Others must as well, because the stations wouldn't be playing it this
soon unless their research showed dopes like me are listening to it.
XM has seven, count 'em seven, different stations in the all-holiday format, ranging from pops, holiday traditions, current pop, soul, Latin and Hanukkah. As for this blogger, I have the two local stations programmed, along with XM's traditions and pop. I could do more, but as it is now, going back an forth between the four may cause a traffic accident.
As for the non driving periods, I have 26 Christmas CD's, and another holiday 325 songs on my iPod. Some are as old as Louis Armstrong and Bing Crosby, and some as recent as this week's iTunes purchase of Kelly Clarkson's new release.
With this background, I though it would be a good time to take a look at the list of Top Ten best holiday songs ever, which I first put together in my newspaper column last year. There have been some revisions, corrections, etc.
Let me start off by saying there will be no barking dogs, braying Italian donkeys or annoying singing chipmunks here. Nor any lisping kids with missing choppers.
Ditto for “White Christmas” (although we will see Bing later on) and “The Christmas Song” (chestnuts roasting on an open fire). To me, they are the holiday equivalent of “Free Bird” and “Stairway to Heaven”, that is to say, they have been way too overplayed.
With that bit of blasphemy out of the way, let's get to the list.
I will start with an honorable mention. Anything Brian Setzer has done on his many Christmas CD's is worthy of this or any other list. Two of the best are his versions of "Baby It's Cold Outside" and "O Holy Night." Both have been recorded scores of times of course, but these stand out. In "Baby," Ann-Margaret duets with him, and sounds just bad-girlish enough for the song. As for "O Holy Night", well, for a man known for his guitar playing, just listen to this vocal.
Now, on to the Top 10:
10) “The Hanukkah Song”, Adam Sandler. Any song which can include The Fonz, The Three Stooges, and Mr. Spock, while taking a shot at O.J. Simpson has to be included. Plus, Sandler plays a nifty guitar while managing to come up with an amazing number of words to rhyme with “Hanukkah.”
9) “Santa Claus Is Coming To Town”, Bruce Springsteen. The Boss' live take on this classic borrows from the Phil Spector/Crystal's arrangement, but gets the nod here because of the blistering Clarence Clemons saxophone solo. And, like the Hanukkah Song, it is a live recording.
8) “Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas”, Judy Garland. Garland introduced this sad Christmas tune in 1944's MGM flick Meet Me In St. Louis. Her expressive voice is perfect for the song's melancholy subject matter. The song has been recorded countless times (I have ten versions on my iPod), and had some lyric changes (Frank Sinatra found the “until then we'll have to muddle through somehow” line depressing, and asked lyricist Hugh Martin to change it, hence the “Hang a shining star upon the highest bough.”) Plus, it was played in The Godfather, which is reason enough to include it here.
7) “Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)”, Darlene Love. Love quite simply lays down one of the most powerful vocals ever recorded here, backed with Spector's Wall Of Sound arrangement. First released in 1963, Love still performs the song on David Letterman's show every year, and has lost nothing off her fastball.
6) “Santa Baby”, Eartha Kitt. This ode to selfish Christmas materiality is given a wonderfully naughty take by Kitt. I always imagined her in her Catwoman costume waiting for the big guy in red come down the chimney. This version blows away the dopey Madonna cover which was needlessly recorded years later.
5) “Peace On Earth/Little Drummer Boy”, Bing Crosby & David Bowie. Told you I'd get Der Bingle on the list. I have always loved this medley, which makes the seemingly mismatched pairing of two icons from completely different eras work. I remember watching when they performed this on Bing's 1977 TV special, which was aired a few weeks after his death.
4) “Little Saint Nick”, Beach Boys. Released during the height of the 'Boys' 1964 popularity, this is really nothing but one of their car songs given a holiday slant with sleigh bells. Which means a tasty Brian Wilson arrangement, nasally Mike Love vocal, and flawless harmonies. Why should Santa settle for a sleigh, when he can get the job done much faster with a little bobsled we call the ol' Saint Nick?
3) “Santa Claus Is Back In Town”, Elvis Presley. When the King released his first Christmas LP in 1957, all the controversy centered on his version of “White Christmas.” Which makes it quite ironic no one seemed to have issue with this song with a winking obvious double meaning about what looks to quite a special visit between Santa and his hostess.
2) “Christmas Time Is Here”, Schroeder. OK, not actually Schroeder, but his stand in, Vince Guaraldi. No list of holiday classics is complete without something from the A Charlie Brown Christmas. Guaraldi's sparse jazz arrangements perfectly fit the mood of the anti-commercial holiday spin Good Ol' Chuck displays during the show. If you think I should have included “Linus and Lucy”, “Christmas Time Is Here” or “What Child Is This” from the same album instead, well, I have no argument.
1) “Sleigh Ride”. Leroy Anderson's composition about a snowy trip is the greatest holiday song ever written. Only problem is figuring whose version is best. The original recording from the Boston Pops is classic, as is the composer's own version, but are they better than Johnny Mathis' jazzy reading? Or the Ronette's ring-a-ling-a-ling ding-dong-ding take? And was Ella Fitzgerald's vocal better than Karen Carpenter's? Plus, especially in the wake of his recent death, how can we forget Andy Williams? Actually, when it comes to this great tune, there are no losers. It'll nearly be like a picture print by Currier & Ives.